Andrea Bangert, 30.10.01
Up
In his philosophic manual, The
Enchiridion, Epictetus teaches that some circumstances - emotions such
as desire and aversion, temperance, and morality, for example - are within
the individual's power to control, while others - such as fate, sickness,
health, poverty, infamy, and death - are not. The individual possesses
control over his own emotions, opinions, and actions, but he has no power
over fate or over the actions or opinions of others. Seeking to control
circumstances over which the individual has no power will merely lead to
frustration. One should seek to avoid only those negative circumstances
which are within the individual's scope, and refrain from both aversion
and desire when contemplating events beyond that scope. Such events ought
to be neither feared nor desired, but must simply be dealt with to the
best of one's ability.
Epictetus particularly wished his
doctrine to be applied when consulting an oracle. At this time, one must
remember that any happenstance which is beyone one's personal control
should be considered neither desireable nor fearful, and should therefore
be neither sought out nor avoided. The purpose of conferring with the
oracle is to determine what event will happen, not whether the result of
that event will be 'good' or 'bad'. Says Epictetus, "When you have
recourse to divination, remember that you know not what the event will be,
and you come to learn it of the diviner; but of what nature it is you knew
before coming... For if it is among the things not within our own power,
it can by no means be either good or evil... First clearly understand
that every event is indifferent and nothing to you, of whatever sort it
may be; for it will be in your power to make a right use of it, and this
no one can hinder." (p.30)
The consultation of oracles plays the
part of a catalyst in the Sophoclean tragedy Oedipus Rex. The King
and Queen of Thebes, Laius and Jocasta, are persuaded to abandon their
infant son upon a hillside to die of exposure after hearing of what his
fate will be if he lives. Recalls Jocasta, "There was an oracle once that
came to Laius,...and it told him that it was fate that he should die a
victim at the hands of his own son, a son to be born of Laius and me...
Before three days were out after his birth King Laius pierced his ankles
and by the hands of others cast him forth upon a pathless hillside."
(p.41) Oedipus, the adopted son of the King Polybus and Queen Merope, is
persuaded to flee their city of Corinth when he hears the fate that lies
in store for him: "Phoebus foretold... desperate horrors to befall me,
that I was fated to lie with my mother, and to show daylight to an
accursed breed which men would not endure, and I was doomed to be murderer
of the father that begot me. When I heard this I fled... to somewhere
where I should not see fulfilled the infamies told in the dreadful
oracle." (p.45) Neither King Laius and Queen Jocasta nor the young
Oedipus possess the self-control counciled by Epictetus which would enable
them to refrain from fearing the prophesied events and instead to meet
them with decorum.
Epictetus insists that circumstances
such as fate, which are beyond the individual's control, must be neither
feared nor desired. He warns that in fleeing from or striving toward
circumstances which the individual is powerless to control, one sets
onesself up for failure. Epictetus would counsel calmness and dignity
upon receipt of an oracle such as those given to Laius, Jocasta, and
Oedipus. He would caution against acting out of fear or attempting to
avert a fate which cannot be averted. Epictetus would urge all parties
involved to accept the roles assigned to them by the gods and to strive to
act out their parts with grace and dignity. This sense of dignity and
morality would not admit to the abandonment of a helpless infant on a
hillside; nor would it involve fleeing in a panic from the city where one
was raised. It would require that the King and Queen raise their
threatening child, and that Oedipus remain in the city of his childhood to
face the fate that the gods had designed for him. If Laius and Jocasta
had kept their son, he would have grown up knowing who his parents were
and would not then have been able to unknowingly commit the crime of
patricide or to take his mother as wife. If Oedipus had stayed in the
city of Corinth, where he was raised by Polybus and Merope, he would not
have come into unheeding contact with his birth parents. By calling their
fate evil and seeking at all costs to avoid it, Oedipus, Laius, and
Jocasta brought disaster down upon their own heads. Epictetus would claim
that the only possibile way to "make a right use of" one's fate is to meet
it proudly; Sophocles' characters assuredly compounded the tragedy of
their fates by being unwilling to do so.
Sophocles' story of the downfall of
Oedipus seems to argue that there is no escaping fate, no matter how
fiercely one battles against it. Epictetus does not dispute this.
Indeed, he claims that one should not resist fate, but should instead
follow the path assigned to one by the gods with grace and composure. In
the Enchiridion, Epictetus quotes Cleanthes in order to communicate his
point:
Conduct me, Zeus, and thou, O Destiny,Epictetus insists that one must with good composure accept the fate designed for one by the gods, and seek to live the most upright life possible within the confines of destiny. However, Oedipus cannot do as Epictetus councels and accept his destiny calmly. Instead he rages against every twist of fate, and refuses to accept his lot with cheer or grace. The Messenger describes Oedipus' behavior upon learning that he is Queen Jocasta's child by the murdered Laius: "Oedipus... burst upon us shouting and we looked to him as he paced frantically aroung, begging us always: Give me a sword, I say, to find this wife no wife, this mother's womb, this field of double sowing whence I sprang and where I sowed my children!" (p.66) Not only does Oedipus rail helplessly against Jocasta, but he does himself a hideous injury, which wholly neglects to alleviate his predicament and instead merely increases the pathos of the situation: "...He tore the brooches - the gold chased brooches fastening her robe - away from her and lifting them up high dashed them to his own eyeballs... With... imprecations he struck his eyes again and again with the brooches. And the bleeding eyeballs gushed and stained his beard - no sluggish oozing drops but a black rain and a bloody hail poured down." (p.66) Oedipus in no way follows Epictetus' council of temperance and stoicism.
Wherever your decrees have fixed my lot.
I follow cheerfully; and, did I not,
Wicked and wretched, I must follow still. (p.39)
Who'er yields properly to Fate is deemedThe Queen Jocasta proved wise when it was time for her to leave the stage, yielding gracefully to fate. In the end, even Sophocles' intemperate Oedipus is a wiser and humbled man who accepts his fate and follows with dignity whence it leads.
Wise among men, and knows the laws of Heaven. (p.39)
Bibliography:
Oedipus the King, Sophocles, translated by David Greene, 1991
The Enchiridion, Epictetus, translated by Thomas Higginson,
1948